A lot of people seem to wonder if the oil and/or sugar water taken on this diet are simply placebos. Sugar and oil, from what I can remember, have both been used as placebos in the past, so I guess it makes sense to wonder.
Another possibility I haven't seen brought up is the Hawthorne Effect. Basically, if you know some change is supposed to give results, you give the results. Very similar to the placebo effect.
I think these arguments miss the point.
This seems to be working for a lot of people. Provided, of course, that it continues to work, does anyone really care if it's a placebo or Hawthorne effect?
I don't.
Technorati tags:
Diet
Weight Loss
Health
Food Craving
Kathy Sierra
Seth Roberts
Freakonomics
Shangri-La Diet
Shangri-La Diet
Placebos
Psychology
Hawthorne Effect
3 comments:
Thanks for posting the link at Seth's forum. I have added you to my Google Reader list. I am looking forward to your posts!
Congrats on sticking with it.
Thanks!
I've been thinking a lot about this diet recently, and I hope in the future can post a lot that hasn't been said before.
Post a Comment